In reply to Rob Greenwood - UKClimbing:
Hey Rob - interesting isn't it, how a thread like this stirs once-dormant urges?
I recommend routes that others have suggested - Trundle Warfare is a classic quarry climb, The Big Flea is also great - take a cam 4/5 for good luck and be careful of the loose flake low down - you'll see it easily enough. The Thin Man & The Shabby Tiger are both good lines, with an entertaining pop for the top if you're less than 5'10 on the Tiger. The Emergence of Talos as mentioned above is scary - that pillar has been teetering for nearly 100 years so it "should" be fine - but it is precariously balanced! Anything on Mythology Wall with a star is worthy, as is Mounties Go Anywhere at E1. A couple of lines at the far left of MW are good - Ride the Waves, Bowsprit and the alternative finish to that "One Quick Peep" are all great. I recruited Pete Whittaker for that after we'd polished off an LGP at Rolliick Stones that morning, the legendary & "impossible" Dana (E5 6c). I'd seen the alternative finish to Bowsprit and thought it was likely E4/5 with zero gear. How wrong I was - and that taught me never to give up a project to someone without at least abbing down it first.
Overhang Buttress is classic - The Primer is very good indeed which a chap such as yourself with devour with pleasure, and the E4 of Crowden Pillar is neat and protectable. The others i haven't done but look good and hard. The E1 (Rhodeswood Crack) right of Crowden Pillar is a good straight fight in the best traditions of grit.
Enjoy!