In reply to fmck:
> I wondered about that. If they had bases on either end that rotated maybe they would sit better.
That might be a great idea, or possibly a terrible one.
(I don't know, but I slightly suspect the latter!)
The faces are angled a bit and the idea is that it sits at a slight angle with the end that you clip into uppermost. The ring isn't there to crank up and really compress it into the sides of the crack, the idea is mainly that the ring locks it securely to the length the spring takes it to and then it's the camming action that makes it hold as the load pulls the upper end down and torques it into the crack - not so much a miniature Acro prop, more a sort of adjustable hex.
Perhaps the difference between my experience of trying to use them (particularly on grit) and beardy mike's experience is simply my own incompetence. I tried plenty of looking for a dish or knobble and lots of shimmying it about a bit - and the way I remember my experiences found I was completely with him up to and including "it might rock about a bit", just very much less confident on the "it's never coming out" part.
Mind you, I never did have the nerve to actually fall on one so perhaps it was just a lack of faith.