In reply to UKC/UKH Gear:
Detailed reviews as always! I agree that Windproofs are probably the most versatile of outdoor gear (next to grid fleece!). I use mine all year round (appropriately layered) more than waterproof for sure.
Any reason why two brands had 2 tops featured ? When nearly all brands produce multiple styles of windproof. I'm guessing other brands didn't reply to request to supply gear for review ?
My favourite Windproofs; Patagonia Houdini, been very durable, packs away to next to nothing, good all around balance of protection/breathability/weight. Montane feather lite smock, very similar to houdini but roomier for layering under for winter biking.
Black diamond alpine start more breathable and less windproof for all day use, but more suited for mountaineering than others.