Back the Ban on Driven Grouse Shooting Opinion

© Tim Melling

Where are all the birds of prey that you'd expect to see on Britain's heather moors? Conspicuous only by their absence. Raptor persecution is the dark secret of our uplands, says environmental campaigner Dr Mark Avery, and the grouse shooting industry is to blame. But don't just get mad – get active.

When you stand on top of a hill or crag to admire the scenery, it's a life-enriching experience. Many of Britain's greatest views are in our upland National Parks, places like the Peak District, the Yorkshire Dales or the Cairngorms. These were set up to protect the beauty of their landscapes and the natural beauty of their wildlife. But here's the rub - our national parks are not wildlife hotspots but wildlife crime hotspots, and that's because they are dominated by a land use, intensive grouse shooting, that does not tolerate wildlife such as Golden Eagles, Peregrine Falcons or Hen Harriers.

Hen harrier
© Gordon Yates

It's difficult to find a place beautiful if you know it hides an ugly secret: shooting lots of grouse for fun is underpinned by wildlife crime by gamekeepers and other shooting interests.

You don't have to take my word for it. In recent weeks several National Parks and AONBs have voiced their concern and outrage over the scale of illegal killing of birds of prey in their areas. Here are just a couple of examples:

'Being able to watch birds of prey in the Peak District National Park should be part of everyone's experience. We have been working with landowners, gamekeepers and partners since 2011 to remedy the situation locally but it is clear from the results that much more needs to be done. This year peregrines have failed to breed in the Dark Peak for the first time since they recolonised in 1984 and persecution of these incredible birds has been a factor in this. This has to change'.

'The continuing persecution of birds of prey in the [Nidderdale] AONB is outrageous. It is a stain on our reputation as a nationally-protected landscape in which wildlife – including birds of prey like buzzards, red kites, hen harriers and peregrine falcons – is part and parcel of what makes Nidderdale such an amazing place to be. We unreservedly condemn illegal persecution of birds of prey. It is starting to have a damaging effect on tourism businesses.'

Those are examples of a whole range of hard-hitting statements that show that the people who live in protected landscapes are fed up with wildlife crime which diminishes their areas, and diminishes the likelihood that walkers, or birdwatchers such as myself, will visit those places. It's difficult to find a place beautiful if you know it hides an ugly secret.

Red grouse wondering if it's safe to come out yet  © Tim Melling
Red grouse wondering if it's safe to come out yet
© Tim Melling

The root of the persecution of birds of prey is the conflict between grouse shooting and raptors. A single day's grouse shooting on a top moor will set you back many thousands of pounds, and otherwise rather economically worthless moors will change hands for millions of pounds because of their grouse shooting income. There's a lot of money at stake.

But birds of prey don't pay for the privilege of eating grouse, and they don't wait until the start of the grouse shooting season on the so-called Glorious 12th of August to take their share. Birds of prey can greatly reduce grouse bags and so they are shot, poisoned and trapped by grouse shooting interests. I'm not suggesting that all grouse moors kill birds of prey, but the scale of killing is immense. There should be over 300 pairs of Hen Harriers, a gorgeous bird after which the Harrier jump-jet was named, nesting in England each year but in 2017 there were just 7 pairs. That illustrates the scale of the killing – all of which is illegal, and has been since the Protection of Birds Act of 1954 (over 60 years ago).

"It's unlikely that grouse shooting will be banned any day soon, but the call for a ban will eventually force governments north and south of the border to act more quickly on this subject"

Shooting lots of grouse for fun is underpinned by wildlife crime by gamekeepers and other shooting interests. Between 1990 and 2015 176 people were convicted of raptor persecution offences in the UK and more than two thirds of these were gamekeepers. Even the British Association for Shooting and Conservation recently said that there are 'criminals among us' who risked 'wrecking shooting for the majority' and 'All of us need to realise that the killing of raptors is doing us no favours. It risks terminal damage to the sport we love'.

Ex-bird, cause of death unclear - the Birders Against Wildlife Crime website explains what to do in this situation  © Dan Bailey
Ex-bird, cause of death unclear - the Birders Against Wildlife Crime website explains what to do in this situation
© Dan Bailey

The RSPB's take on the subject is this:

"In the UK we have a major issue with birds of prey being deliberately and illegally killed, despite full legal protection. This type of crime has serious consequences for the conservation status of species such as the hen harrier and golden eagle … Of particular concern are raptors targeted in the uplands, especially on land managed for driven grouse shooting."

Under such a wide consensus that wildlife crime is rife and its source is grouse shooting we might expect government to act. In Scotland the SNP government has frequently condemned the scale of wildlife crime and has commissioned studies to investigate the matter, to look at the economic and environmental problems of grouse moor management (which go way beyond killing of raptors and include increased flood risk and water pollution because of heather burning, damage to blanket bogs, new tracks and fences marring the landscape and peat degradation and carbon loss) and they are considering taking legislative action. But in England, the Conservative government remains unmoved. It's almost as though they are mates with the rich and titled who own and manage many of our grouse moors – what a thought!

Dr Mark on a grouse moor, hunting for raptors in vain  © Mark Avery
Dr Mark on a grouse moor, hunting for raptors in vain
© Mark Avery

So, the next time you stand on a peak and look at the view, if it contains a patchwork of burned heather look hard for birds of prey because you probably won't see them. You've been robbed of the sight of a majestic eagle or a Peregrine Falcon, the world's fastest bird, stooping on its prey. And you should feel angry – it certainly makes me angry.

But don't just get mad, get active. Here are some things to do which will channel your anger into helping to solve the problem:

  • Sign the new e-petition which calls on UK authorities to ban grouse shooting - it's unlikely that grouse shooting will be banned any day soon, but the call for a ban will eventually force governments north and south of the border to act more quickly on this subject
  • Would you know what to do if you found a dead bird of prey out on the hill? Read the Birders Against Wildlife Crime website which tells you how to Recognise, Record and Report wildlife crime – it's a very good guide
  • To learn more about the evils of intensive grouse shooting and the campaign against it read my book Inglorious – Conflict in the Uplands
  • To get up-to-date news on illegal raptor persecution bookmark the website Raptor Persecution UK - it's a real eye-opener on the scale of crime and the reluctance of the authorities to tackle it

About Dr Mark Avery

Dr Mark Avery is a scientist by training who is now a blogger (see here), author and environmental campaigner. He worked for the RSPB for 25 years and was their Conservation Director for 13 years.

Support UKH

As climbers we strive to make UKHillwalking the kind of website we would love to visit, with the most up-to-date news, diverse and interesting articles, comprehensive gear reviews, breathtaking photographs and a vast and useful logbook system. As a result, an incredible community has formed around the site - we’ve provided the framework but it’s you who make the website what it is today. If you appreciate the content we offer then you can help us by becoming an official UKH Supporter. This can be a one-off single annual payment or a more substantial payment paid monthly or yearly which includes full access to Rockfax Digital and discounts on Rockfax print publications.

If you appreciate UKHillwalking then please help us by becoming a UKH Supporter.

UKH Supporter

  • Support the website we all know and love
  • Access to a year's subscription to Rockfax Digital.
  • Plus 30% off Rockfax guidebooks
  • Plus Show your support UKH porter badge on your profile and forum posts
UKC/UKH/Rockfax logo

22 Nov, 2017
Was in the hills east of Dalwhinnie a couple of days ago. Whilst I had a brilliant day out, thanks great company, endorphins and a dusting of snow, it was also marred by excessive hill tracks, heather desert, no raptors, rusty old traps lying about and the remains of mutilated mountain hares. These are not wild places. :(
22 Nov, 2017
I live in Lancaster, next to the Forest of Bowland. Local people, particularly in Abbeystead, have rallied around the cause of the Hen Harrier - which they suspect has been illegally persecuted by gamekeepers working for the estate of the Duke of Westminster, which owns vast tracts of moorland in the area. All so that some assholes in landrovers can rag it up the hillside, and get pissed on single malt whilst murdering hundreds of grouse - which, bless it, is literally the stupidest and slowest bird in the world. They might as well take their shotguns into a hen house. So, who is the Duke of Westminster? An anachronistic leech, whose assets total somewhere around £9.5 billion. When the Duke of Westminster died in 2016 he managed to avoid inheritance tax on the fortune left to his son [1]. The recent 'Paradise Papers' revealed how a network of offshore companies was used to avoid tax [2]. As the aptly named Dr. Avery says, we don't need to wonder why the Tories don't do something to stop this kind of crime. The same scum who run the Tory party are the ones who are trying to turn moorland into a barren theme park for inbred, (en)titled pricks. Nevermind prosecuting them, or fining them - we should confiscate this land. After all, they already owe us more than its value in avoided tax. [1] [2]
22 Nov, 2017
Your sentiment is right, but you do realise the Guardian who you linked also offshores it's profits in the Cayman islands. Brexit and the demise of CAP is likely to slowly change the benefits, or lack of, owning vast swathes of unfarmed land (Crops or forest ).
22 Nov, 2017
banning shooting is probably not the answer here it has been around longer than clmbing probably and is part of county life providing employment for people etc. (though it needs to be regulated properly). the problem here is lack of enforcement of existing laws and lack of funding for enforcement officers. we need to fund enviromental enfocement through the police and EA, and prosicute people untill this happens nothing will change
22 Nov, 2017
Tbh, I think very little of 'country life' and its 'employment opportunities'. I've only met one grouse gamekeeper, but he was treated like crap, paid a pittance, expected to work every hour of the day, and often victim to the parochial politics of this 'idyll'. At one point, one of the shooters ran over this guy's dog, and didn't even apologize; that seemed to me symptomatic of the kind of arrogant disregard these people have for those who work for them. I reckon better and more meaningful work could be created if this land was taken over and conservation replaced shooting... Though Summo may be right in thinking that Brexit is likely to throw the whole economics of land ownership, farming and conservation projects into chaos, as the web of organisational relationships and subsidies is ripped apart... I'd love to think that something more progressive might take the place of these organisations handing millions of pounds to already wealthy land owners... but I somehow doubt that the Tories will be the ones to institute this...
More Comments
Loading Notifications...
Facebook Twitter Copy Email LinkedIn Pinterest