In case anyone cares this is how I do my Photo Voting:
5. Excellent, I would like a poster on my wall.
4. Good. Woud probably put it on my wall as 5*7 for a couple of weeks
3. With an autofocus camera most people could take this. Subject is not striking.
2. Something not right, focus, colour bleeds, image too small, no sense of perspective, lots of artifacts etc.
1. Why did you even bother putting this up, you had to know it was wasn't making the grade? probably most of the elements from 2 are wrong.
Modifying factors:
Bum/back shots -1
Landscapes +1
Bouldering -1
Bouldering shots of someones fingers -2
Sunsets -1
Few glasses of wine - leads to harsher critism. -1
Vodka, random effect -2 to +2
Click to list photo comments written by me. (10 comments) I've voted for 1,014 photos, average vote 3.2. (7% superb - 27% good - 43% average - 18% poor - 1% rubbish)