In reply to Iain Thow:
> Yes, I wondered that too. Pigott's on Cloggy is 5a so he would have been capable of doing it, but surely it would have been recorded if he had.
The problem was there were a number of different clubs going to these (then) not easily accessible crags, and identical routes got given different names. One reason why unravelling the first ascent of Kelly’s Overhang, for example, is so difficult, because one of the clubs called it the ‘Inaccessible Overhang’ or some such, IIRC.
Pigott was a very capable climber, who definitely led Kelly’s Overhang - perhaps even the first genuine ascent. I was fortunate to be able to get in touch with, and meet, his son Geoff Pigott - who was also a very good climber - when I did my Peak book. He told me lots of amusing stories about his father, who was famously unflappable.