In reply to Gaston Rubberpants:
I'm unlikely to be offended by some random person I don't know sat behind a keyboard, if I were I'd be a pretty weak minded individual.
You're entitled to your thoughts on it of course. Sure I've done plenty of mountain and sea cliff routes with loose rocks and not felt the need to mention it. This one just stood out as particularly large with potential.
Perhaps my description of it as 'loose' wasn't very good. It's not loose, it's sat there unbound from the crag, and I pulled on it from below where I couldn't see it before I grabbed it.
Id be surprised if that rock in particular has been there since 1948 or whenever it was you last climbed the route.
Id have chucked it off and said no more if I could guarantee no one was there, I couldn't guarantee that so I left it.
Anyway, lesson learned. No further informative posts on routes that may detract from the purity of mountain trad.