Messner Mystery solved after 30 years

© claka
Investigation into the DNA of a bone sample brought back from the Himalayas by Rheinhold Messner has cleared up the long-standing mystery over what happened to Messner's brother Gunther, when he and Rheinhold descended the mountain in 1970, according to Messner.
For years there has been a fierce dispute over what exactly happened on the descent with several notable figures accusing Messner of sacrificing his brother for his own ambition when he sent him down the wrong way. This year Messner returned to Nanga Parbat, acting on information from several previous expeditions about human remains on the mountain. Messner located this body which he strongly believed to be that of his brother, and which was found in a location which supported Messners version of events and not the accusers. This DNA evidence has now confirmed what that the remains were indeed his brother vindicating his original story although the K2Climb web site is reporting that this particular feud is far from over.

This post has been read 2,840 times

Return to Latest News


22 Oct, 2005
So the location where the remains were discovered seem to confirm Messners version of events... I wonder if Max von Kiemlin will retract his accusations? I doubt it. I think the accusations were more to do with personal enemity than anything else. Still at least it displays Kiemlin as the vindictive litte sh1t I always thought him to be.
22 Oct, 2005
Excellent news. I never doubted him for a moment. Let's hope he gets a public apology.
23 Oct, 2005
Seen the rather aggressive allegations posted on this website? http://www.k2climb.net/news.php?id=808 The report appears to be anonymously by-lined - you do wonder whether Von K and his pals have had anything to do with it. However, if accurate, the questions about the 1980s clothing and boots are intriguing. And how far does can the much-vaunted DNA evidence be regarded as conclusive? (Not that it's at all important, I'm just keen for this entertaining soap opera of egos and reputations to continue...which I'm sure it will)
24 Oct, 2005
"Yesterday the professor who carried out the tests told the Guardian that there was a 17.8m-to-one probability the bones had come from Günther Messner" So no, it's not conclusive. If 18 million other people had died in that spot, the chances are high that the DNA of one of them would also match. Which is more than enough for most conspiracy theorists.
Loading Notifications...
Facebook Twitter Copy Email