Chee Dale Railway Proposal Rejected After Feasibility Study

© ROCKFAX
The proposal to reopen the railway down Chee Dale and Water-cum-Jolly has been rejected. The following statement was made by those conducting the feasibility study -

Stage 1 Feasibility Study into the reopening of the Buxton to Matlock railway has found that reopening by 2011 would not be financially sound, though in the longer term there may be more demand. There was no evidence os significant modal shift (people changing the way they got around) and net environmental gain. The consultants recommended the existing corridor should be safe-guarded for 20 years but that any further development work be limited.
Derbyshire County Council will give its formal reaction to the recommendation later in the summer.

Derbyshire Wildlife Trust will be reviewing current access arrangments, for access to crags in Chee Dale, with the BMC next week. If there are any points you wish to raise about these access arrangements then do so by the thread below.

This post has been read 3,160 times

Return to Latest News


16 Jun, 2004
This is good news, its just worrying that it lost out due to economic arguments rather than the fact that this is a national park and shouldn't be developed anyway. What does this mean? Do they have specific concerns or do they do this sort of review regularly anyway?
16 Jun, 2004
Reopening a railway is hardly developement, infact it's restoring something which was there before national park status was granted. It's hardly going to make much of an impact on the landscape, as all the earthworks are already there.
16 Jun, 2004
Of course it is development. It would restrict access to areas of a National Park, it would bring added noise to areas of a National Park and it sets a precident that National Park status is menaingless in the face of economic arguments. Besides the people most likely to benfit from such a scheme would be the quarry owners at the end of the Dale.
16 Jun, 2004
Wouldn't taking traffic off the roads be an advantage? If the railway was already there, would you be demanding its closure as it'd restrict access to parts of the national park?
16 Jun, 2004
Yes, but it seems that the study has concluded that it wouldn't do this.
More Comments
Loading Notifications...