In reply to Siward:
> Another vote for army ones. I have a Dutch army one in supposed vapour permeable goretex, it is big, roomy and robust. Yes it weighs more than a lightweight alpkit or survival zone but that's still less than virtually any tent.
If a bivi bag does its job and keeps you dry, any extra weight is soon compensated by not carrying wet sleeping bags.
In rain, the only times I have remained dry is when rigging up a small tarp, so as not to have to breathe into and through the bag.