In reply to PPP:
Proper boots all the way for me - Meindl Borneo - leather lined, no Goretex and a tough sole. They get worn every day for dog walking, plus cragging. Should last me ten years, like the last pair. Should work out at £20/year therefore. Two months in, they're fairly well broken in so that my foot now 'slots in', as opposed to me 'putting a boot on'.
I loathe sweaty Goretex footwear. If someone shows me a Goretex-lined leather boot, my immediate question is 'What's wrong with the leather?'.
I don't need 'super-grippy' soles on walking boots - I need something that will stand up to some battering.