In reply to angry pirate:
> Have you tried one on? It looks a little short to me. I used to have a Paramo Torres belay smock which was chock full of insulation but was short so didn't cover the bum well and I always cold in it. I now use a Rab Alpine Generator which has much less filling but is a cracking length and is much warmer as a result.
I've not tried it on, so have no idea about the sizing, but I take your point about longer being better!
Appreciate the thoughts re:hood, I've emailed Keela to see if their separate one attaches to the jacket.