Was at Chee Dale yesterday with a friend when two parties turned up, one with a fairly mellow dog, the other running about all over the place, muddying up all the ropes and getting tangled in them, running right underneath us climbing. At one point the dog came over and decided to have a ruffle through my new-ish Peak Limestone book, completely ripping out 5 or 6 pages. Then the more mellow dog decided to hunt through someones stuff and eat their lunch. One of the owners came over and called back the unruly one at this point but completely blanked me and did not even apologise or acknowledge us. I just stewed because I don't enjoy confrontation and it just makes me more angry.
Should owners apologise on behalf of their dogs? Am I being overly unfair? It was a young and very energetic dog, but shouldn't owners show a bit more respect for other climbers, tether it up if it's being a nuisance etc? I generally love dogs and am all for crag dogs, but this was a particularly frustrating encounter...
Those dog owners sound like idiots. Nothing wrong with dogs at the crag if they are under control
Dogs aren’t unruly. Owners on the other hand…
Glad I'm not the only one. In hindsight should have spoken my mind but was in that slight state of disbelief at their lack of apology that leaves you a bit speechless...
Did they see what their dog was up to or did you say anything?
Yesterday on my run through one of the Glasgow parks I had a St Bernard playfully run along with me then nip me on the thigh. Not hard, no damage done but enough to go "Ow, what the fck". Pretty sure it wasn't aggressive, if it was from something that size I don't think I'd have been upright but a few words with the owner were definitely needed who was rightly mortified
Ouch, yeah probably playful intent, but still.
They saw it clear as day but no one chose to say anything... they just carried on chatting and then one lady sat with the dog for a bit with her back turned from me, before promptly letting it run riot again!
I think a shouting at was completely in order....give dog owners bad reputations...shows climbers can be dicks too....
Commiserations, a dog ate my lunch once and it qas apparently my fault for leaving my bag on the ground.
As a dog owner who sometimes takes my dog to the crag if that had been my dog I would have been very apologetic, offering to buy you a new guide book and lunch.
Next time, spike your lunch with something that will make the owners to never let their dogs go foraging ever again. 😀
I'm hyper aware when I take my dog to the crag as I know that not all people like dogs and that's absolutely fine! If no one is there he can charge around and do whatever he wants but if others are there he gets tied up, especially at cheedale as he likes swimming!!
It's hard but definitely tell the owners their dog is being a knob. If they get frustrated at you it's only because they're embarrassed (trust me, I've had it!!!) Sorry about your lunch and guidebook!
People that brings dogs climbing are complete twiats, my close circle of friends included. In fact, especially them
A few years ago I was looking for a spot to stop, eat my sandwiches, and have a coffee from my flask, when I saw a neatly stacked wood pile in the field a few yards off the public footpath that I was walking. I'd just got comfortable and had got out the sandwiches, when I saw a man approaching with two loose dogs, which made a bee line for me and started trying to eat my sandwiches, and were generally shoving their noses into the rucksack which was open. So I shouted at him "Will you PLEASE keep your dogs under control, and call them back!"
Quick as a flash he shouted back, "Will you PLEASE stop sitting on MY log pile!"
There was a stunned silence, then we both burst out laughing
Remember, some people's "Ickle Doggos" can do no wrong.....
> Should owners apologise on behalf of their dogs?
They shouldn't need to. They should control their dog.
If a dog goes over to someone belaying, the owner should call it back; belayer doesn't need the distraction. If the dog starts interfering with bags, ropes or guide book, they should call the dog back and teach it not to do that again.
Last week I had to use the "call.your dog off please" shout and the reply? "He's only a puppy". Wtf
It seems to be the new version of "he's only being friendly"
As a crag dog owner I definitely wouldn't be letting my dog behave in that way. He has stolen someone's lunch before but in his defense he was on the lead and there was an open pre packaged sandwich unattended on a rock next to the path which I didn't spot until he snaffled it.
Going through bags is unacceptable but I'm always surprised at the amount of people that spread their stuff all over the bottom of the crag and treat it like a climbing wall!
> As a crag dog owner I definitely wouldn't be letting my dog behave in that way. He has stolen someone's lunch before but in his defense he was on the lead and there was an open pre packaged sandwich unattended on a rock next to the path which I didn't spot until he snaffled it.
To be fair, this is not a defence
> Going through bags is unacceptable but I'm always surprised at the amount of people that spread their stuff all over the bottom of the crag and treat it like a climbing wall!
Guilty as charged. I'm trying to retrain myself on this one!
I think most dogs would consider tasty food left on the floor fair game although I did tell him off for it as obviously it's not behaviour that should be encouraged!
Its poor practice on the owners part - it was in a area where livestock graze and a greedy sheep taking fancy to the food/ packaging could result in said sheep becoming quite Ill.
> Next time, spike your lunch with something that will make the owners to never let their dogs go foraging ever again. 😀
Apparently it's the owners who are the problem, so why ruin your own lunch? Spike theirs with something which will make them never see their dog again. Ok, might as well dispatch the dog as well.
"he never normally does this" is my favourite.
> I think most dogs would consider tasty food left on the floor fair game although I did tell him off for it as obviously it's not behaviour that should be encouraged!
You reacted just how I would like a dog owner to react
> Its poor practice on the owners part - it was in a area where livestock graze and a greedy sheep taking fancy to the food/ packaging could result in said sheep becoming quite Ill.
I agree, and I'm not entirely innocent on this one. Although if there are livestock/wild animals around I do try to keep everything locked securely in my bag
The next time an uncontrolled dog jumps up at me or my kids and slobbers on us when we're out on a walk and tells me "he's only being friendly" I'm going to do the same to it's owner. I'm pretty sure they'll change their tune.
I love the levels of intolerance and threats that threads such as this expose.
It is very fortunate that we are all a lot less unpleasant in real life than we are online.
> I love the levels of intolerance and threats that threads such as this expose.
> It is very fortunate that we are all a lot less unpleasant in real life than we are online.
No-one should have to tolerate someone else's dog running over their ropes, chewing their guidebook and eating their lunch. Pretty basic stuff. Like picking up the poop. You can't say: well, if you don't like accidentally treading in my dog's sh1t, perhaps you shouldn't come to the crag.... You are responsible for your dog in public. Full stop. I write that as a dog owner, and one who would be mortified if my animal had behaved in the way described.
I think it was the RSPCA that originally had the motto "all dogs should be fed to other dogs until only one dog remains, and it should be put in a zoo".
I'm not so extreme and I've definitely mellowed with age. Dogs bring a lot of people a lot of happiness but I would say that the owner needs to control their dog if their dog is not capable of controlling itself. There are lots of people who go over to someone's dog and say "hello gorgeous, etc etc" and that's fine, the problems only start when it's the other way around because there are lots of people who don't like being approached by a dog (particularly if it's about 4 feet high, built like a brick sh**house and baring bloodsoaked fangs) so the basic rule for me is that the dog should be on a leash if it doesn't respond to a recall order from its owner or its owner is otherwise occupied and not able to control it.
In your situation I think I might have asked the dog owners if they had a guidebook. If it was in good order I'd probably suggest swapping now that their dog had mauled my one. I'd definitely have said something about putting the dog on a leash.
In reply to henwardian:
> What you doing still in the UK then?! America is waiting for you with open arms! Hahahaha
I would consider shooting even the unruliest of dogs with a semi-automatic weapon jolly unbritish and unsporting; just not cricket.
I normally get: 'he's never done that before' ... yeah, right
On the other end my Border terrier as a pup would get all excited meeting anyone. I would shout him back but they would say "it's alright he's just being friendly" Little did they know he was squarting piss all over their legs in excitement. He was on lead but some people cant resist a puppy. It sure learned them!
Why would you have to shout him back if he's on a lead? How about controlling your dog?
I think your dog just ate my chocolate bar…
I was once at a crag when a stray unruly dog suddenly swept over my shoulder, stole a doughnut out of my hand, and flew off to eat it on top of a streetlight!
When I tried to shin up the light pole to retrieve at least some of the doughnut - they were very tasty doughnuts - the dog sqwaked at me, shat on my head, and flew off to a tree.
The owner didn't seem to be around, and it should certainly have been on a lead.
My mistake... Just reading that back, it wasn't a dog; it was a seagull.
And it wasn't at a crag; it was on Llandudno promenade.
You get the gist, though?
Long leads don’t always help do they.
Last Saturday at ParkRun I was sat down on a bench bent over tying my running shoes up and a dog, on a long lead, ran up to me and licked my face…I didn’t see it coming and it took me completely by surprise. Very disconcerting…
2 weeks prior to that I was stood looking at a warbler in a hedgerow with my binoculars and felt a punch/nip on my calf…dog on a lead had simply run up to me tried to bite me. It did have a muzzle on, but again disconcerting that it would do that…
I had a similar experience, I was readying myself for a long lonely lead when a dog shat in my chalkbag.
No, I keep getting mixed up. I was waiting for a ferry when a seagull shat in my Guinness.
I once was converting a ship yard in Glasgow into a recycling yard. Didn't know where the dog was if he was eating a climbers pieces or mounting a sit start boulderer.
Started to shout his name then spotted him going like ten to the dozen towards me. Unfortunately I was on the other side of a factory concrete floor pour. Yep he got about 10m in and sunk in and I had to walk in to fish him out and hose him quickly. There were trowels flying about I can tell you.
A cracker on the last Highlander MM. We'd got to the top of the last big climb and my knackered partner sat down for a well earned buttie, only to have it stolen out of his hand by the SAR dog belonging to the marshal at the check point. Shouldn't have laughed but the look on his face was hilarious 😂. A definitely psychological hoof in the knackers!
> You get the gist, though?
Not really; I don't know anyone who keeps a seagull as a pet, especially not as a notionally-trained pack animal pet.
My dog Jessica Anabelle is 17 years young, not much sight, not much hearing, and a little bit of Dementia. The vet though says she is happy enough.
When we go for a walk with her, the owd lass just want leaving alone, so when someones dog comes a bounding up, she just does not like it, and I take huge exception to the owner saying it just wants to be friends. In fact I get agitated and sadly I express this to the owner. There is a huge universe for peoples dogs to bound about in, they can go anywhere they want, but please avoid the couple of square meets that I and Jessica Anabelle are in, or it just gets unpleasant. So how people keep their dogs out of my 2 square meets I have no interest, maybe a lead or just training, just do it.
Or how about the Dog that knocked my Wife of her Bike on a Sustrans route. The owner whose dog was off the lead tried to face me off when I got agitated, but then I got even more agitated, and suggested that as my Wife was on the ground and her bike might be damaged and that I might start damaging him, he pissed off.
Or how about the dog owner with her dog on a 10 yard long lead that tripped me up and she laughed and said she was sorry, and I suggested that she was not sorry, because if she was she would not have a her dogs lead so long across a path and would not have laughed.
I have been around Dogs since birth and love them, but I totally despair of Dog owners nowadays who treat their dogs like little children and have no respect for other people. Its no wonder people get angry when dogs are running all over the place and jumping up at them, and just being a nuisance.
On a par with the cyclist version of SMIDSY.
Biking home from work this week down an old railway line and a Jack russel decided to attach itself to my foot! Apparently I was going too fast, although I was at a standstill and no longer moving when it bit. I tried having a polite word, no aggression or anger but apparently "you cyclists are all the same, it's always someone else's fault". Sometimes you just can't argue with stupid.
In that vein, we were climbing at the riverside in Cheedale with my friends old spaniel asleep by the river. A Jack Russell off the lead attacked the spaniel, whereupon my friend grabbed it and lobbed it into the river. The owner remonstrated loudly until he was threatened with the same and quickly did one.
At crowded Cornice in Cheedale a well known climber decided to throw a hefty stick for his dog. As he let fly he overbalanced from the boulder he was standing on but let fly anyway. The stick hit me on the forehead. He made a half-hearted apology.
I am designing a device that is based on one of those dog calming devices (high pitch signal that dogs hate but we cant hear) that will be constantly beeping and can be placed in your rucksac.
The second BMC Members Open Forum webinar took place on 20 March. Recently-appointed BMC CEO Paul Ratcliffe, President Andy Syme and Chair Roger Murray shared updates on staff changes, new and ongoing initiatives, insurance policy changes and the current...