In reply to Gordon Stainforth:
Surely when it comes to good meandering routes at the Roaches then Valkyrie has to win? 38m so quite a bit longer than Pedestal (even with the Neb finish). Still not as long as Don't Look Back though ( which gets *** in my 1990 guide)
I have climbed on Kinder Great Buttress incidentally, although just Great Slab, easier and shorter than DLB. The rock was fine then (80s) but it all looks pretty lichenous these days. Enjoyed Mermaid's Ridge too, as you say, a cracking route.