In reply to baron:
> I’m still waiting for the herd of SNP politicians to come out and trumpet the righteousness of the Scottish legal system like they have been all too keen to do until quite recently.
I think the judge was right, even though he's a Tory, and I don't say that often
You've got to read the judgement rather than go on the media reports and you'll see this is far from a victory for Boris. What the judge says is that the Advocate General for Scotland who is also an officer of the court has formally stated that the government will not break the Benn Act and will not try and thwart its purpose. That formal statement is enough and he doesn't need to make an order.
That seems fair to me because Boris hasn't actually broken the Benn Act yet and a court has to give credence to the word of its own senior officers and the government. The flip side of that is that if the court is lied to by the government and Attorney General it is a serious matter.
If Boris's intention is to not send the letter he is in a significantly worse place now than he was before.