In reply to PaulScramble:
> ...... can't understand how working class English people with experience of previous Labour governments can be so stupid.
I think you’ve been neglecting your Ladybird History Book. Here is a selection of things done by Labour which just might have improved the lives of the working class.
Attlee, 1940s: Put into effect many of the demands of the Beveridge Report – NHS, National Insurance (Sickness and Unemployment pay), secondary education for all up to 14 years.
Wilson, 1960s and 1970s: The Open University. Many progressive social reforms like suspension of death penalty and decriminalisation of what gay men did in private (I know you wouldn’t approve of these, but you’re in a minority)
Callaghan, 1970s: introduced capital gains tax, Race Relations Act
Blair, 1997 – 2007: Minimum Wage, Sure Start, reduced pensioners poverty numbers from 3 million to 2 million, the Good Friday agreement, tax credits, improved the NHS hugely (reduced waiting lists massively).
I don’t know if you’re just ignorant of all these things or bizarrely believe they haven’t improved the lives of working class people.
I would also point out that all these reforms were opposed by the Tory opposition of the time, and it’s noticeable that they haven’t really tried to reverse any of this progress.