Chrome books

New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
 rockwing 18 Jul 2019

My Windows10 laptop has just died and I need a replacement. It's mostly for MS Office stuff, so the obvious choice would be an Windows laptop, but I'm really not a fan of their formats and layouts any more. 

Anyone got any experience with the newer ChromeBooks, especially in regards to using MS Office?

 girlymonkey 18 Jul 2019
In reply to rockwing:

I have had a chromebook for a few years now. Love it. Still as quick as ever, none of this clunky slow windows nonsense. 

No problem with online versions of word etc. All pretty much the same as an offline one, but faster!

 JoshOvki 18 Jul 2019
In reply to rockwing:

I had a chromebook a few years back and loved it. Then google did a firmware update and bam the wifi started to cut out (not ideal being something that requires the internet for full functionality). I suffered with it for 6 months, changing routers a few times because they blamed that, lots of reports the of the same thing online, so binned it and bought another laptop. It was great up until then. So I wouldn't rate their support, if you are going down that route google for the Chromebook you are thinking about getting and "problems"

In reply to JoshOvki:

Google are like a child; they get a new toy, play with it exclusively for a while, and then get bored and forget all about it.

Operating systems: ChromeOS, Android, and now Fuschia. How long before they get bored with ChromeOS and Android...?

Post edited at 00:02
 Pullhard 19 Jul 2019
In reply to captain paranoia:

forgive my lack of knowledge could you install windows or Linux on it? 

 Luke90 19 Jul 2019
In reply to Pullhard:

Most Chromebooks can easily run Linux (ChromeOS is a version of Linux anyway), though it won't necessarily run all that well on the cheapest models. Most of them will also run Linux software and/or Android apps inside ChromeOS these days.

 topper133 19 Jul 2019

Macbook all day for me, but depends on what you use (and budget). Requiring internet to work is a no for me, limits the use cases.

 Neil Williams 19 Jul 2019
In reply to rockwing:

> My Windows10 laptop has just died and I need a replacement. It's mostly for MS Office stuff, so the obvious choice would be an Windows laptop, but I'm really not a fan of their formats and layouts any more. 

> Anyone got any experience with the newer ChromeBooks, especially in regards to using MS Office?


You can't run proper Office on a Chromebook - the whole point of it is that it's a browser-based machine for doing everything online.  I think you can now run the Android apps and Office Online but they're not a real substitute.

For running Office you need a Windows machine or a Mac.

Post edited at 09:40
2
 girlymonkey 19 Jul 2019
In reply to Neil Williams:

What have you found that you need from office that you can't do online? Most people only ever really use word and Excel, both of which are absolutely fine online. I have never regretted not having windows!

 Neil Williams 19 Jul 2019
In reply to girlymonkey:

> What have you found that you need from office that you can't do online? Most people only ever really use word and Excel, both of which are absolutely fine online. I have never regretted not having windows!


I don't like Office Online as an everyday tool, it's slow, clunky and unresponsive compared with the proper native version.  It's also dependent on an Internet connection so no use for e.g. working on the train or on a campsite where it can be patchy.

If you find Office Online faster than regular Windows Office, your Windows machine was underspecced.

Post edited at 11:40
1
 girlymonkey 19 Jul 2019
In reply to Neil Williams:

>  It's also dependent on an Internet connection so no use for e.g. working on the train or on a campsite where it can be patchy.

I use phone tethering if I really need to use the computer outside of the house, but since my phone is basically a small computer I mostly just use it these days, even in the house! I only really use the chromebook (which is the closest to a proper computer that I have) when I am doing translation work and need to type a lot as it is then quicker to have a proper keyboard.

> If you find Office Online faster than regular Windows Office, your Windows machine was underspecced.

I always bought the cheapest machine that I thought I could get away with - there are always more bikes and tents to buy with that money so I won't waste it on a boring computer! But for the same price as a really basic and clunky windows machine, I have a fast and simple chromebook which works really well and doesn't get slower and crapper with age. 

XXXX 19 Jul 2019
In reply to girlymonkey:

The reviewing and track changes functions work poorly for me. I tried to use my Chromebook for a part time masters and it was a grind.

 Neil Williams 19 Jul 2019
In reply to girlymonkey:

> I always bought the cheapest machine that I thought I could get away with - there are always more bikes and tents to buy with that money so I won't waste it on a boring computer! But for the same price as a really basic and clunky windows machine, I have a fast and simple chromebook which works really well and doesn't get slower and crapper with age. 

My present Windows laptop is a £400 HP which is quick enough (8GB RAM is the key with Win 10).  I'll probably have knackered it before it gets frustratingly slow.

 girlymonkey 19 Jul 2019
In reply to Neil Williams:

I paid £200 for my chromebook, and I think it has 4GB RAM. How do you knacker it other than it getting slow? I have found every windows machine needs replaced within a couple of years due to getting too slow. The chromebook must now be at least 3 years old , maybe nearer 4? And from switching on to using it takes about a minute. No updates or any of that nonsense. It just works, and works, and works! I'm not interested in fancy tech, I just want tech which makes my life easier, doesn't cost a fortune and doesn't need replaced too often!

 girlymonkey 19 Jul 2019
In reply to XXXX:

I think I am probably a more 'simple' user of these things!! I didn't really need to track changes etc.

 Tyler 19 Jul 2019
In reply to Neil Williams:

> I don't like Office Online as an everyday tool, it's slow, clunky and unresponsive compared with the proper native version.  It's also dependent on an Internet connection so no use for e.g. working on the train or on a campsite where it can be patchy.

By Office online, that's different to an Office365 subscription isn't it? I can use my work office365 subscription on additional devices but that's no use if I need to be online 

 Neil Williams 20 Jul 2019
In reply to girlymonkey:

> I paid £200 for my chromebook, and I think it has 4GB RAM. How do you knacker it other than it getting slow?

I travel a lot (though not as much as I used to) and so my laptop tends to lead a hard life.

> I have found every windows machine needs replaced within a couple of years due to getting too slow.

Sometimes doing a back to box reinstall helps that assuming it's not a spec issue.

> The chromebook must now be at least 3 years old , maybe nearer 4? And from switching on to using it takes about a minute. No updates or any of that nonsense. It just works, and works, and works! I'm not interested in fancy tech, I just want tech which makes my life easier, doesn't cost a fortune and doesn't need replaced too often!

To be fair if it works for you by all means use one - I just wouldn't recommend it for the original poster's use-case.

 Neil Williams 20 Jul 2019
In reply to Tyler:

> By Office online, that's different to an Office365 subscription isn't it? I can use my work office365 subscription on additional devices but that's no use if I need to be online


Depends on the Office 365 subscription.  Most likely a work one includes the installation of the software itself rather than just the online version.

 girlymonkey 20 Jul 2019
In reply to Neil Williams:

The OP wasn't very specific about usage, just said MS office stuff. 

It's pretty easy for the OP to try all the online versions first to see if they are suitable for their use! 

 Neil Williams 20 Jul 2019
In reply to girlymonkey:

> The OP wasn't very specific about usage, just said MS office stuff. 

> It's pretty easy for the OP to try all the online versions first to see if they are suitable for their use! 


True.  I would still suggest, though, that if MS Office is your primary aim the online tools *won't* be adequate for most people - they are not even nearly the full product, they are more like a M$ version of the Google Suite.


New Topic
This topic has been archived, and won't accept reply postings.
Loading Notifications...