In reply to GridNorth:
> I've accumulated several soft shells over the years
It's a slippery slope...
In reply to thread:
Being a sad, gear-obsessed nutbag, I have a whole wardrobe of softshells, dating back to an ME Aquafleece (I'm not going to give a count...), as well as simple wind-resistant shells. They range from Aldi & Peter Storm to Patagonia and Cloudveil (no Arc' because it doesn't fit me, and even I baulk at their prices).
As others have said, the biggest difficulty is in identifying what you mean (want) by 'softshell':
0. simple windshirt (e.g. Pertex Classic, Microlight, Quantum, etc)
1. stretch nylon (or mix) (e.g. Schoeller Dynamic)
2. stretch dual-weave (e.g. Schoeller Dryskin)
3. shelled micropile (e.g. DriClime, Rab VR)
4. 'perforated membrane' (e.g. PowerShield)
5. insulated 'perforated membrane'
6. insulated laminated membrane (often used on cheap softshells, e.g. the likes of Aldi and cheap skiwear, but can also be expensive like Schoeller WB-400 or 'classic' Gore Windstopper)
7. full waterproof membrane fabric with fluffy inner scrim (e.g. Gore 'Windstopper SoftShell').
The latter isn't softshell; it's just Malibu Stacey with a different hat...
My current favourite for general use is a Patagonia ReadyMix (long obsolete), being a simple, uninsulated, wind- and water-resistant hooded shell (type 1) with pockets in sensible places. The fabric is nice and smooth, with a dense, wind-resistant weave.
But I also like the shelled micropiles (type 3), and even insulated things like the MixMaster (type 5: great for skiing).
The Rab Exodus mentioned above uses a fabric that looks very, very similar to that used by Decathlon for their Simond mountaineering pants (which is a Good Thing, if you want a robust type 2 softshell).
Talking of Decathlon, the last softshell I bought was this strange offering (on a good discount):
http://www.decathlon.co.uk/softshell-spread-for-900-men-id_8304400.html
a bit like a shelled micropile in concept, only the pile is bonded in hexagonal clusters. It has non-piled areas, and is a slim fit with long arms and thumb loops. The pockets would be better if mounted higher up. I'm not entirely convinced by it, as it's less wind resistant than I like, but that may be a bonus, depending on your preferences. No adjustment on the hood.
One other suggestion might be the Montane Alpine Stretch (type 2), currently discounted in a number of places; a bit like the ReadyMix, but less wind resistant.
Post edited at 18:14