In reply to Rob Greenwood - UKClimbing:
I take it the "freezer test" wasn't actually done in the freezer, right?
To get a reasonably useful comparison of their performance in the cold I left all five models, fully charged, in the freezer overnight, at a cool -20. I then [removed them from the freezer]* turned them on at full power and set the clock going...
* - added by me, but it's strongly implied from "emerged from the freezer", "came out of freezer" and such further in the review.
I don't think that's the best methodology, it says more or less just how fast each battery+torch combo warms up to house temperature and not much how it works in the cold. Perhaps a frozen webcam on manual exposure recording the torches inside could work well enough? You could even stream it...
Of course, I get it, not even UKC has some industrial freezer facility to run full tests in with. Although it would be quite a sight - reviewer stomping around in a big freezer warehouse, holding a stopwatch with cold hands while looking at torches. He could even test sleeping bags or belay jackets at the same time! You should definitely consider it
But the rest of the review is good, with extensive usage outside (like always here) that tells a lot!