Staying Alive This Winter

© CampbellForbes
photo
coire an t-sneachda
© ericoides
Thoughts on how to reduce the death and injury rate among UK winter climbers.

Last winter there was a big increase in the early season deaths of UK winter climbers, all of them taking place around Coire an t-Sneachda in the Northern Cairngorms. The British Mountaineering Council pointed out that although each incident occurred in different circumstances, one common factor was the proximity and ease of access to the Coire.

“It is important to recognize that although it is relatively easy to access the Northern Corries of the Cairngorms, the terrain is as serious as any in Scotland and the full range of mountaineering and climbing skills are needed to manage the risks involved. Some of the skills are technical but equally important are judgement and decision-making. It takes time to acquire these skills.”

Part of their statement focused on four factors that are of particular importance to climbers.

This short article aims to expand on these factors, in the hope of possibly reducing the risk involved in winter climbing in the UK.

photo
Scottish Winter
© Erik B

Pay heed to the weather forecast and avalanche report and choose objectives that are appropriate.

One of the things you notice about good winter climbers in the UK is their knowledge of winter conditions and weather.

Neither should be based on the day you plan to climb, but on the days or weeks before, and ideally you should make a note of weather and conditions every day through out the winter. This could be nothing more than setting your web browser so that the first thing you see is the weather and conditions. Many websites are a great resource for conditions, with Scottish Avalanche Service being by far the most valuable, along with the two associated blogs for Lochaber and the Northern Cairngorms.

Making a habit of checking these sites (whether you plan to climb or not) will both increase your understanding of how conditions on the ground have developed, how quickly the change, and more importantly help you to pick up a great deal of valuable beta on how to avoid being killed in an avalanche.

One of thing to note is to take heed of what the SAIS people say. They are not health and safety obsessed civil servants. They are ballsy climbers who push it, so when they say stop and go down the wall, drink tea in Aviemore, or buy some new picks then listen up.

Try and read up on avalanches and weather safety, with books like Chance in a million? and The Cloud Spotters guide being highly recommended. If you have the type of learning process that work well by using books then there are tons of great books out there, both old and new, with Martin Moran's Scotland's Winter Mountains still about the best all round guide. If you're not a book type then have a look out for instructional DVD's like the BMC's Winter Essentials. Hopefully YouTube will start having more technical content for climbers soon.

photo
Winter climbing is fun!
© CampbellForbes

Be well equipped with both warm clothing and the appropriate technical gear.

If you read all the clothing articles on my website Psychovertical.com then there is no way you will die from hypothermia. Remember that Scottish conditions are potentially 100% more extreme then those found in the Alps, in fact they are more like Patagonia, with super high winds, high humidity, snow and fast changing ground conditions. You have to treat every trip like a mini expedition. THERE ARE NO ROADSIDE WINTER VENUES!

If you're new to UK winter climbing expect the worse (always carry bothy bag, food, head-torch. spare clothes). Spend the summer and those bad weather days out on the hill building up your fitness (fatigue plays a big part in many climbing rescues), and more importantly your navigation skills. Go on a navigation course, buy another book, learn how to use a GPS. These skills will save your bacon, and can even be fun!

Don Whillians claimed that his biggest asset once he went to the greater ranges was fell bashing in the mist in the Peak District, teaching him to navigate and push on in bad weather.

photo
Lemmings on the Ben
© hwackerhage

Adopt a progressive approach to adventure. Develop skills incrementally by choosing objectives that build on previous experience.

The two most dangerous periods in a climbers life are when they are new to winter climbing but super keen, and when they believe they are so good they can let down their guard and ignore the warning signs.

If you're new to winter climbing find some one who will take you along and pass on some skills. If that's not possible then I would highly recommend either going on a winter climbing course at PYB or Glenmore Lodge, or better still employ an experienced guide for a weekend or week and tell them you want to learn as much as possible (the cost isn't that high between two, and for example people like Rich Cross or Al Powell would no doubt pass on a couple of years of knowledge in a single climb).

Doing this will save you a lot of time and money learning those initial skills, and help you step over that dangerous gap between your ambition and your dream climbs.

Another option is to try and get on a subsidised Conville Course, which will speed up your winter skills.

If that's not possible then try and progress slowly and carefully, and use the web to get advice from others on good safe climbs to try (take any advice with a big pinch of salt unless you know the advice is trustworthy).

photo
First ice screw blows...now.
© Toby_W, Jan 2007

Don't be influenced by the hype that surrounds adventure activities in the 21st century. It is not always best to “go for it”.

Learning when to “go for it” and when to “go home” is something that comes with experience and all experienced climbers will attest to having many near misses. Remember that good judgement comes from experience and experience comes from bad judgement. I would never want to dissuade anyone from going after their dreams, but you must always keep your ego and ambition in check, think about the consequences of every action, expect the worse, be paranoid and most importantly of all stick to the buttresses.

Finally UK winter climbing can be - and often is - the most extreme test for any climber, an environment that will incapacitate anyone who is found wanting very quickly. It is testament to our tiny hills and big weather that although we have no Alps or big walls, the skills that are demanded from these wild places have allowed the British climber to punch above their weight for nearly a century. Remember that when you're 'just' going to the Northern Corries.


photo
Andy Kirkpatrick
© Ian Parnell
Andy Kirkpatrick has climbed throughout the world, carving a niche for himself by surviving terrible weather in the world's most hostile mountain ranges. These extreme experiences have added up to make Andy an expert in mountain survival. His words are worth listening to.

  • Andy is sponsored by Berghaus and has a Berghaus Team Blog
  • Andy is also sponsored by: Petzl, Ortlieb, Beal, La Sportiva, Exped, Julbo, Jetboil, Faders, Outdoor research, Tubus and Gripmaster. You can find out more about these brands at the Lyon Equipment website.
  • Andy has his own excellent website PsychoVertical.com which is full of useful articles and gear advice
  • You can watch a video of Andy in action in Patagonia on the Alpinist website

For more information PsychoVertical.com

25 Dec, 2007
I liked the article since it goes straight to the point without much long and boring explanations... good for newbies and good it comes from such well known characters. One concept tickles my curiousity: Learn from a course... I see the point when it says you'll save time and potentially eliminates some of the risks taken unwittingly. however two thoughts came to my mind and I would like to see what people make of them: a) Climbing is all about learning to objectively see risks and assess them. if you don't see the risks for yourself and start small (=small risk) and increase it over a course of a few months/years to do big(=big risk) how are you suppose to learn for yourself. kind of warning kids on bikes... don't go too fast you might fall... well didn't we all not listen and fell once?? b) Taking a course makes you go on the mountain faster and on harder ground faster without all these years of pottering yet seeing what the weather can be like... That is to say, you have been shown, but have you digested it enough, does it not make you overconfident and put you faster on grounds that could be beyond you? I have been seriously pondering these ideas for a while and can't come to a satisfactory conclusion... + old the household names never went to courses they learned the hard and long way and indeed made mistakes and had nearmisses... is this not why they are now so proficient? See my problem!!! What do you think?
26 Dec, 2007
I tend to agree with you Erick, looking back the near misses I had when starting out was climbing in really bad weather, i dont think a course prepares you for this as I doubt guides take you out in such weather, I also agree with you that going on a climbing course might instill a false sense of security in that you may think you know it all. I did actually attend a course in my first season at glenmore lodge, this wasnt a climbing course but more a mountain awareness type thing, avalanche awareness and how to stop yourself sliding too far etc and i think this wass highly beneficial (although ive never used these snow belays since!) generally speaking the technical aspects of climbing is not the part of winter climbing that will kill you, statisticaly descending from the hill is the most dangerous part (usually in the dark). It is during these descents when your knackered and coming down from the adrenaline high when you will more likely trip or take undue risks crossing/descending loaded slopes. Also I think andy saying that if you follow his clothing mantra from his site then you will never get hypthermia, i think this is incorrect and misleading, 2 of the deaths last year probably discounts this theory, exhaustion and injury and extreme weather (eg fluctuatons between warm and cold) can result in hypothermia no matter what you are wearing. I also think eating habits should have been highlighted as this is key and is something I took a while to learn, a fish supper the night before wont set you up for a long day on the hill, but a huge plate of pasta will, and lets not forget bevvy, bevvying the night before seriously affects you and your body the next day (take note students!) I think too much has been read into the sneachda deaths last year, they all had different characteristics and to me is more symptomatic of the huge increase in popularity of the sport and the hyping up of the northern corries by the media. having had a good few struggles early season in these corries the most dangerous aspects about them is the height, the location and the terrain, the car park is at 2500ft (not far off munro height), the terrain is hard with lots of large scree and boulders (holes only covered in powder early season) making walking a nightmare particularly when your knackered and in the dark in a white out walking into a northerly (most people dont know the good route through the scree) and the location is that they face north with no other mountains in the way to offer shelter from northerly storms coming off the north sea with nothing but hundreds of miles of open sea for the winds to gain momentum before they hit the n corries.. still, good to have such articles by the likes of Kirkpatrick as he is a high profile figure who will be listened to, so well done andy and ukc and all the best for 2008! as always, lets hope the winter actually kicks in properly this time!
26 Dec, 2007
A fair point, but if you don't take some stuff in on a course then you'll probably end up learning it through your own experience - so nothing lost there. If you do take it in, in this instance always gear up somewhere safe, then it doesn't matter much how you learned it. Maybe there's a point about self-learning which makes you better able to judge the risks and reasons for certain habits which is better. Rather than just "knowing the rules" you are assessing them, so you know when to ignore them.
26 Dec, 2007
*Most* of the people I know/have met that have done courses have been the sort of people who take the risks seriously enough to want to learn from a guide. But I think your view here will certainly apply to some. Through our university club we've run leading courses, and these do seem to produce a few who think they've done the course now they're an experienced climber. In reality I think this is caused mostly by the courses being too easily accessible, it's on a plate for them, I think people who've had to be more proactive about doing a course would be less likely to have this attitude. (Also not helped by mostly being guys aged between 18 and 23 obviously!)
26 Dec, 2007
I think many household names are that for this reason, that they were pushing the boat out and had a few close calls. They may not have done courses, but from what I understand most of them (Admittedly not all!) were mentored in some way by much more experienced climbers, something which happens a lot less today I think.
More Comments
Loading Notifications...
Facebook Twitter Copy Email