In reply to BnB:
> It's a pity that last year's "hot" pack, the Patagonia Ascensionist, isn't included. It's main rival, the Arcteryx FL gets a going over. I was interested that the reviewer siezed upon the reasons I rejected it in favour of the Ascensionist: carrying comfort and the sweat-inducing fabric. Well spotted and a thorough review.
Ditto. I went for the Ascensionist 35 too last winter (for Scottish climbing) and have been so impressed by it that I've bought the 25 and 45 versions too, both of which have also majorly impressed! Remarkable that such a light bag (the 35) is such a comfortable carry, even when loaded for an overnight. Of course, there are things about it that other bags do better, but as the total package I'm not seeing a serious competitor.