I tried it on a climbing wall. Its fine to fall on, but it lacks a bit of padding for rock climbing. It should be great for winter climbing. I just wondered about other peoples thoughts / experiences .
It's a bit light on gear loops, isn't it? I suppose you could stick a fair bit on a bandolier, but there's some things I'd prefer on the waist (ice-screws in particular)
Yes you are correct on the gear loops. However I have two large gear loops on my rucksack, and my screws are on a bandolier in flutes. I also have gear on a second bandolier so it works for me