In reply to Tom Ripley Mountain Guide:
> I'd avoid anything made from neo shell or event. They work well to begin with but very quickly start to fail. Gore tex is the gold standard and will last longer.
Have you owned a neoshell jacket or is this speculation based on the proven unreliability of eVent?
I have a neoshell jacket and pants, and gore active pants, and a goretex pro jacket. And I've owned goretex for nearly 25 years. My current goretex items are both too sweaty for comfort in active mode although more comfortable on the belay. The neoshell is far more breathable, stretches better, rustles less and is a pleasure to wear on the move but you can feel the extra breathability when you're stood still. Belay jacket definitely required.
As for durability, the supposedly ultra tough Tupilak from ME in goretex pro rips every time it sees rock. To be fair I haven't owned the neoshell items long enough to comment on durability but I can definitely confirm that, like goretex, it isn't crampon-proof!!